Not too long ago, I’d often use the Was That Wrong? trope to highlight outrageous attorney misconduct.
This story gets its own post.
Yesterday, the New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Judicial Department suspended a lawyer’s license for 4 months. The lawyer’s violations included telling an unrepresented opposing litigant “you’re one of those people in the world that really should just kill themselves because you’re worthless.” Above The Law, the New York Law Journal, and the New York Post reported the decision, which is here.
The lawyer’s misconduct involved two different matters. In the first, and per the decision, the lawyer entered an arbitration, took pictures of a witness who was testifying, and said to the witness:
- “This will be in the newspaper when I put this in there after we kick your asses. You should be ashamed of yourselves for kicking people out of a building and you have to live with yourself.”
The second matter? Well, I’m not sure you’d believe me. So, I’ll quote from the decision:
“In the second matter, respondent’s firm represented the owner of several residential buildings. A resident of one of these buildings, James Dawson, allegedly made postings to a website accusing the owner of overcharging tenants. Respondent sent a letter to Dawson dated September 7, 2016, accusing him of creating a false and defamatory website and demanding that he take it down or face a lawsuit. Respondent received no response to this letter.
On September 13, 2016, respondent sent Dawson a text message which read, in relevant part:
‘We are filing a lawsuit against you for millions of dollars of damages you have caused as a result of your defamatory website. . . . We are also in contact with the location [sic] police station and we have a copy of the complaint your ex-girlfriend filed against you and we will be using all means necessary to protect our clients.’
Later on the same day, respondent telephoned Dawson, who recorded the conversation. Respondent told Dawson, inter alia, that Dawson was ‘not that bright,’ and that, if he did not take the website down, he would ‘be bankrupt soon.’ Respondent told Dawson that he ‘should commit suicide. . . . [y]ou’re one of those people in the world that really should just kill themselves because you’re worthless.’ While still on the phone with Dawson, respondent said to a person in his office about Dawson ‘start the lawsuit. . . . I need him arrested. . . . I gotta get this guy. He’s gotta be arrested.’ Respondent told Dawson that respondent’s employee who would be ‘running the investigation’ of Dawson ‘used to run the district attorney’s office,’ and claimed that respondent’s office was ‘in contact’ with the District Attorney’s office. He told Dawson, ‘[y]ou have no idea what you stepped into. . . . Welcome to my world. Now you’re my bitch. . . . you’re gonna be paying for this heavily for the rest of your life.'”
In case you still don’t believe it, the recording of the conversation is here.
This story reminds me of a conversation that broke out during a CLE I did at the VBA Mid-Year Meeting; a conversation that prompted me to suggest: be nice to someone today. This is but another reminder.
Because the conduct? Yes, that was wrong.