Last night, I filmed another in the Garage Bar series of CLEs: Pro Bono & Professional Responsibility. It includes some of my thoughts on the need and the key rules to remember. It’s 30 minutes, which brings the Garage Series to 6 hours since we started isolating. Keep rowing!
Friday’s questions are here. The answers follow today’ Honor Roll.
- Penny Benelli, Dakin & Benelli
- Andrew Delaney, Martin Delaney & Ricci Law Group
- Jennifer Emens-Butler, Education & Communication, Vermont Bar Association; VBA Past-President
- Erin Gilmore, Ryan Smith & Carbine
- Laura Gorsky, Esq.
- Robert Grundstein, Esq.
- Keith Kasper, McCormick, Fitzpatrick, Kasper & Burchard
- Jack McCullough, Project Director, Vermont Legal Aid Mental Health Law Project
- Jeffrey Messina, Bergeron Paradis Fitzpatrick
- Hal Miller, First American Title Insurance
- Dan Richardson, Tarrant Gillies & Richardson; VBA Past-President
- Kristen Shamis, Monaghan, Safar, Ducham
- Jay Spitzen, Esq.
- Robyn Sweet, CORE Registered Paralegal, Cleary Shahi & Aicher
- Jonathan Teller-Elsberg, Vermont Law School, JD Candidate
- Thomas Wilkinson, Jr., Cozen O’Connor
How many hours of pro bono legal services do the Rules suggest a lawyer should provide each year?
- A. 50, and the rule applies to all lawyers.
- B. 50, but the rule exempts government lawyers.
Rule 6.1 is clear: “Every lawyer has a professional responsibility to provide legal services to those unable to pay.”
If you’re interested in opportunities to provide pro bono legal services, please contact Mary Ashcroft. Mary is the Vermont Bar Association’s Legal Access Coordinator. Here is a list of several low bono & pro bono programs. Or, check out the Vermont Volunteer Lawyers Project.
I often mention “7 Cs of Legal Ethics.” Each is a single word that begins with the letter “C.” The construct is a helpful tool to remember the basics.
Anyhow, there is a rule that includes an exception that allows a lawyer to do something otherwise prohibited in order “to establish a claim or defense . . . .in a controversy between the lawyer and client.”
What is the “C” associated with the rule?
CONFIDENTIALITY. Rule 1.6(a) prohibits a lawyer from disclosing information relating to the representation of a client. Rule 1.6(c)(3) includes the exception stated in the question.
In Vermont, a lawyer has a duty to take reasonable remedial measures upon learning that a client or witness called by the lawyer has offered material evidence that is false. Per the applicable rule, this includes, if necessary, disclosure to the tribunal. By rule, how long does the duty continue?
- A. until the lawyer is allowed to withdraw.
- B. until the conclusion of the proceeding.
- C. forever.
- D. Trick question. There is no circumstance in which a lawyer is authorized to inform a tribunal that a client submitted false evidence, even if the evidence was material.
V.R.Pr.C. 3.3(c). Per Comment , “[a] proceeding has concluded within the meaning of this rule when a final judgment in the proceeding has been affirmed on appeal or the time for review has passed.”
Former Client contends that Attorney committed malpractice. They meet. Former Client is not represented. Former Client and Attorney discuss a settlement.
By rule, what must Attorney do before settling?
- A. advise Former Client in writing of the desirability of seeking independent legal advice related to the matter.
- B. give Former Client a reasonable amount of time to seek independent legal advice related to the matter.
- C. stop settlement discussions because lawyers are prohibited from settling malpractice claims with former clients who are not represented by counsel.
- D. A and B. V.R.Pr.C. 1.8(h)(2).
Speaking of Arrested Development, the show includes 3 of my favorite fictional attorneys. Julia Louis-Dreyfuss appeared in a handful of episodes as Maggie Lizer, an ethically challenged prosecutor.
The other two attorneys are Barry Zuckerkorn and Bob Loblaw. The former struggles with the duty of competence, while the latter runs the greatest blog in the history of blogs: The Bob Loblaw Law Blog. Here’s Zuckerkorn’s business card. For the question that follows, it’s literally the second biggest hint in the history of hints, behind only the hint in the introduction to the quiz.
Arrested Development debuted in 2004. However, the actors who play Zuckerkorn and Loblaw also appeared together in a popular comedy that debuted in 1974. Name that show that debuted in 1974.
Henry Winkler (Zuckerkorn) and Scott Baio (Loblaw) also appeared together in Happy Days. Kudos to Dan Richardson for noting it was originally entitled both Love and the Television Set and Love and the Happy Days when it premiered as an episode on the anthology series Love, American Style.