Specializing in Anonymity

Our nation’s long national nightmare is over: I’ve returned from my blogging hiatus.

Welcome to Monday!  I hope your summer is going well.  And, for those of you who followed the World Cup, let’s not forget that Scott Mapes predicted 3 of the final four.  Now that’s competence!

Today I’m going to discuss an oft misunderstood rule: Rule 7.4.

By way of background, last week, someone sent me copies of several pages from the “Lawyers” section of the Yellow Pages.  I’m not going to tell you the geographic area.  The sender chose to remain anonymous: no return address, no cover letter, no sticky note with a name.  The sender used a highlighter to call my attention to a few ads that indicate that various lawyer “specialize in” certain areas of law.

I assume the sender thinks the highlighted ads violate the rules.  Absent a cover letter, I don’t know.

I’m not a fan of anonymous complaints.  If you think another lawyer’s ad violates the rules, make a complaint or an inquiry and we’ll let you know.

Back to Rule 7.4.  The rule does not ban any & all use of “specializes” or its variants.  Here’s what the relevant sub-part says:

  • “(d) a lawyer shall not state of imply that a lawyer is certified as a specialist in a particular field of law, unless:
    • (1) the lawyer has been certified as a specialist by a named organization, provided that the communication clearly states that there is no procedure in Vermont for approving certifying organizations, unless the named organization has been accredited by the American Bar Association to certify lawyers as specialists in a particular field of law; and
    • (2) the name of the certifying organization is clearly identified in the communication.”

Comment [1] is instructive.  Per the Comment,

  • “[a] lawyer is generally permitted to state that the lawyer is a ‘specialist,’ practices a ‘speciality,’ or ‘specializes in’ particular fields of law, but such communications are subject to the ‘false and misleading’ standard applied in Rule 7.1 to communications concerning a lawyer’s services.”

In other words, if it’s true, Vermont’s rule appears to allow a lawyer to advertise that the lawyer specializes in a particular area of law.

Image result for saul goodman advertisement


One thought on “Specializing in Anonymity

Comments are closed.