Was That Wrong? Judicial Conduct Edition

Last June, I used this question at a training I did for the Defender General:

  • On May 23, a Nevada judge presiding over a contested sentencing hearing made the news by:
    • A. Ordering the defense attorney handcuffed to the jury  box.
    • B. Holding a defense attorney in contempt for tweeting updates during the hearing.
    • C. Vacating the conviction & confessing to the crime.
    • D. Sending a Facebook ‘friend request” to the defendant during the hearing.

As you think about your answer, I’ll take a moment to explain Was That Wrong? to new readers.

Was That Wrong is a column in which I attempt to use satire to write about conduct that, hopefully, lawyers don’t need a CLE or confidential inquiry of bar counsel to know to avoid. An episode of Seinfeld served as the column’s inspiration.  The entries so far:

Ok. Ready for the answer?  As first reported by the Las Vegas Review-Journal, a Nevada judge presiding over a contested sentencing hearing made the news by ordering the defense attorney handcuffed to the jury box .  The transcript of the incident is here.

Now for the fallout: per the ABA Journal, last week, the judge was publicly censured and banned from the bench.  Here’s how I imagine it on Seinfeld:

  • Judicial Commission: We’re going to get right to the point. It has come to our attention that you ordered a defense attorney handcuffed to the jury box during her client’s sentencing hearing. Is that correct?
  • Judge: Who said that?
  • Judicial Commission: She did.
  • Judge: Was that wrong? Should I have not done that? I tell you I gotta plead ignorance on this thing because if anyone had said anything to me at all when I first started here that that sort of thing was frowned upon, you know, cause I’ve held defendants in contempt and, well, this lawyer kept interrupting me.
  • Judicial Commission: You’re censured. And you can never be a judge again.
  • Judge: Well I’d already lost my re-election so you didn’t have to say it like that.

As always, be careful out there folks.

costanza

Advertisements

One thought on “Was That Wrong? Judicial Conduct Edition

Comments are closed.